374
7. His Excellency might of course have left matters in that state, which he presumes is what you would advise, or he might resort to the other alternative of the Ordinance for "the better limitation and control of Gambling," which is the policy that he considers most consistent with his duty to maintain "Order."
8. Last Month the Colonial Press gave extensive publicity to the Governor's declaration in Council of his opinion that it would be wise to regulate what we could not suppress, and if publicity be un-English, and "calculated to blind-fold "the Public," you will find it in extenso in the reported proceedings of the Legislative Council of the 17th ultimo.
9. His Excellency would have expected from the deep interest which you feel in the question that you would then have avowed your opinions. It will be a satisfaction to you, however, to know that Members of Council, at least all the non-official Members, so far back as the passing of the Ordinance last Year, were well acquainted with and entirely approved of the alternative given to the Executive, if the suppression of Gaming proved impossible. Such also is the opinion of the most experienced residents here, whose opinions are entitled to equal weight with yours, for His Excellency presumes that you do not claim a monopoly of either sagacity or virtue.
10. You allude to the "large Revenue" which Gambling licenses will bring in, and some of your number have published letters imputing to the Government the most sordid motives. Your imputing such motives, when disavowed by the Government, gives them neither truth nor even increased probability.
11. The Governor simply wishes to free Gambling from its present illegality so far as to break up the gangs of illegal Gamblers, whose cliques are now the schools and nurseries of crime, the continuance of which you advocate. He would do so if he saw his way to such a result, without adding a cent to the Public Treasury.
12. He cannot, however, make the Chinese aid in putting down illegal Gambling otherwise than by rendering it essentially their interest to do so, nor can this be effected unless they have a large interest at stake with which illegal operations would interfere. The larger that interest, the greater and more effective must be their co-operation with the Government, and the more stringent the power of the latter to enforce obedience to its Regulations, because that co-operation and obedience must be proportioned to the sums invested and risked by want of co-operation and by disobedience.
13. Nevertheless, when the amount paid is sufficient for the above purpose, a point that can only be settled by experience, it is not desirable to increase it for mere purposes of Revenue, and for that reason, His Excellency has refused offers exceeding the amount accepted by more than $100,000. He will even be glad to find hereafter that a less sum than that now tendered will enable the Government to attain the principal legitimate objects sought, as above stated.
14. In this small Colony, situated within a mile of the mainland, there has been between the latter and this Island an interchange to and fro of 200,000 Persons in the last Six Months, and His Excellency despairs of producing a moral impression against Gaming on a community formed of such changing elements, and the individuals composing which are in the aggregate notoriously addicted to Gaming.
15. He prefers addressing himself to the practical question of protecting property by suppressing meetings of illegal Gamblers and retrieving the efficiency of the now corrupted Police. He does not believe that vice ceases to exist when he shuts his eyes and refuses to see it---and if that, which is a sin of deeper dye, is, from the necessity of the case, submitted to regulated sanction with the approval of the wise and good in England, for the prevention of disease, His Excellency cannot admit the distinction without a difference, which would forbid his endeavoring, with a view to the suppression of crime, to control that which was not illegal by English Common Law, and is not denounced as a sin by the Sacred Law.
16. He believes that under the new policy there will be more Gaming, but by removal of its illegality, the consequences will be far less pernicious to individuals or the Public than its present more limited practice. His opinion on the probabilities of the case is at least founded on information as accurate and extensive as yours---though it may not be so offensively or discourteously expressed as in some of your recent publications.
17. One system has been tried and failed. Therefore another is now about to be tried. Should it also fail, the Governor has reserved complete powers to terminate the experiment at a moment's notice.
18. Finally, His Excellency desires me to add that he does not believe there is any individual amongst you so reluctant personally, as he is himself to introduce a system, the object of which it is so easy for irresponsible declaimers to misrepresent in general appeals to morality for which there will ever be a ready audience, too indulgent to suspect that the morality advocated is but a lazy acquiescence in the same vice under more revolting and dangerous conditions.
19. Argument would be useless with those who can see no difference between the special and exceptional circumstances of Hongkong and Heligoland. What might be an unjustifiable Policy in England, or in a Colony inhabited by a European race with an efficient Police, may be, in the cause of Order and general security, an absolute necessity in a small Community of 72,000 Foreigners amongst 130,000 Chinese, whose co-operation in the suppression of illegal Gambling, the source of so much Crime, can only be expected by giving them an interest in limiting its practice to a few fixed places under Government surveillance.
I have the honor to be,
Gentlemen,
True Copies,
Your most obedient Servant,
(Signed,)
CECIL C. SMITH,
Acting Colonial Secretary.
(ai (.Jatt.
heating (dant Jemeday.
EX
374
7. His Excellency might of course have left matters in that state, which he presumes is what you would advise, or he might resort to the other alternative of the Ordinance for "the better limitation and control of Gambling," which is the policy that he considers most consistent with his duty to maintain “Order.”
8. Last Month the Colonial Press gave extensive publicity to the Governor's declaration in Council of his opinion that it would be wise to regulate what we could not suppress, and if publicity be un-English, and "calculated to blind-fold "the Public," you will find it in extenso in the reported proceedings of the Legislative Council of the 17th ultimo.
may
9. His Excellency would have expected from the deep interest which you feel in the question that you would then have avowed your opinions. It be a satisfaction to you however to know that Members of Council, at least all the non- official Members, so far back as the passing of the Ordinance last Year, were well acquainted with and entirely approved of the alternative given to the Executive, if the suppression of Gaming proved impossible. Such also is the opinion of the most experienced residents here, inen whose opinious are entitled to equal weight with yours, for His Excellency presumes that you do not claim a monopoly of either sagacity or virtue.
10. You allude to the "large Revenue" which Gambling licenses will bring in, and some of your number have published letters imputing to the Govern- ment the most sordid motives. Your imputing such motives, when disavowed by the Government, gives them neither truth uor even increased probability.
11. The Governor simply wishes to free Gambling from its present illegality so far as to break up the gangs of illegal Gamblers, whose cliques are now the schools and nurseries of crime, the continuance of which you advocate. He would do so if he saw his way to such a result, without adding a cent to the Public Treasury.
12. He cannot however make the Chinese aid in putting down illegal Gam- bling otherwise than by rendering it essentially their interest to do so, nor can this be effected unless they have a large interest at stake with which illegal operations would interfere. The larger that interest, the greater and more effective must be their co-operation with the Government, and the more stringent the power of the latter to enforce obedience to its Regulations, because that co-operation and obedience must be proportioned to the sums invested and risked by want of co-operation and by disobedience.
13. Nevertheless, when the amount paid is sufficient for the above purpose, a point that can only be settled by experience, it is not desirable to increase it for mere purposes of Revenue, and for that reason His Excellency has refused offers exceeding the amount accepted by more than $100,000. He will even be glad to find hereafter that a less sum than that now tendered will enable the Government to attain the principal legitimate objects sought, as above stated.
14. In this small Colony, situated within a mile of the mainland, there has been between the latter and this Island an interchange to and fro of 200,000 Persons in the last Six Months, and His Excellency despairs of producing a moral impression against Gaming on a community formed of such changing elements, and the individuals composing which are in the aggregate notoriously addicted to Gaming.
15. He prefers addressing himself to the practical question of protecting property by suppressing meetings of illegal Gamblers and retrieving the efficiency of the now corrupted Police. He does not believe that vice ceases to exist when he shuts his eyes and refuses to see it---and if that, which is a sin of deeper dye, is, from the necessity of the case, submitted to regulated sanction with the approval of the wise and good in England, for the prevention of disease, His Excellency cannot admit the distinction without a difference, which would forbid his endea- voring, with a view to the suppression of crime, to control that which was not illegal by English Common Law, and is not denounced as a sin by the Sacred
Law.
16. He believes that under the new policy there will be more Gaming, but by removal of its illegality, the consequences will be far less pernicious to individuals or the Public than its present more limited practice. His opinion on the probabilities of the case is at least founded on information as accurate and extensive as yours-though it may not be so offensively or discourteously expressed as in some of your recent publications.
17. One system has been tried and failed. Therefore another is now about to be tried. Should it also fail the Governor has reserved complete powers to terminate the experiment at a moment's notice.
is
18. Finally, His Excellency desires me to add that he does not believe there any individual amongst you so reluctant personally, as he is himself to introduce a system, the object of which it is so easy for irresponsible declaimers to mis- represent in general appeals to morality for which there will ever be a ready audience, too indulgent to suspect that the morality advocated is but a lazy acquiescence in the saine vice under more revolting and dangerous conditions.
19. Argument would be useless with those who can see no difference between the special and exceptional circumstances of Hongkong and Heligoland. What might be an unjustifiable Policy in England, or in a Colony inhabited by a European race with an efficient Police, may be, in the cause of Order and general security, an absolute necessity in a sinall Community of 2,000 Foreigners amongst 130,000 Chinese, whose co-operation in the suppression of illegal Gambling, the source of so much Crime, can only be expected by giving them an interest in limiting its practice to a few fixed places under Government surveillance.
I have the honor to be,
Gentlemen,
True Copies,
Your most obedient Servant,
(Signed,)
CECIL C. SMITH, Acting Colonial Secretary.
(ai (.Jatt.
heating (dant Jemeday.
EX
No comments yet.
Private notes are available after approval.